Monday, October 05, 2015

Seattle Conference 2015

Last spring, I went to a conference for the American Planning Association. It was in Seattle, an awesome city I had never explored, and I got to see my cousin Sarah and her husband Evan.

I never blogged about it because it was just soooo much. I did create a photo book for myself. But then finally today I realized I wanted to share the highlights with my work colleagues (some of whom just came back from the state planning conference and are doing the same) -- so I wrote the below email. I thought I would share it here for all the planning geeks out there who love this stuff, or for anyone who wants to understand the type of stuff I spend my day obsessing over. So here's my conference summary email, word-for-word, followed by a few of my favorite pics from the trip.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Hi all,

After I attended last spring’s APA conference in Seattle, I intended to share some of what I heard with everyone. Last summer I tried to do a brown bag but people couldn’t attend, so – better late than never – here are some of the highlights.

New this year was an APA app. Rather than a full conference program, all the sessions were on the app. You could view it in multiple formats and search by topics and themes. You could log your AICP credits right from the app, find information about the conference center, and view all the attendees. As a first-year app, I expected a ton of bugs. Surprisingly, it was flawless. Everyone else I spoke to also raved about how well it was working. I’m hoping that they build social networking into the app for future conferences.

The first session I went to was called a “Deep Dive” – these were the sessions that lasted 3 hours, very in depth. This one was on “The Future of Zoning,” and one of the presenters (there was a whole panel) was none other than one of my favorite zoning experts, Don Elliott. Some thoughts from that session:


  •  Zoning (and buildings) need to be very flexible. “You have no idea what uses you will have in 10 years or how much office space you’ll need in 20 years."
  • With population growth you will need to do all three of these: Infill + Densification + Expansion
  •   “Affordability is a mainstream structural problem of the American economy. It is now costing us more just to live as a human being.” – Don Elliott
  • Why do we regulate? Because the market doesn’t give us what we want or need. How much should we regulate? Just enough. Just enough to protect common interests. Zoning basics: building placement, how it meets the street, transparency, openness.
  •  We cannot extract public benefits from every project. In some cities there is a notion that development itself, in cities, in a sustainable way, is inherently bad. This isn’t true. Good development is a great thing.
  • We need to ENFORCE what we regulate – or don’t regulate it.
  •  Nashville has a new zoning code in the downtown area. They have had $600 million in investment with NO VARIANCES. (Yes, folks, you read that right). They use a form-based code, but they don’t use that term. They call it the “downtown code.” Terminology can be important – the public will likely respond more favorably to “Downtown Zone” vs “T6 Zone.”
  • Austin, TX uses a “Community Character Manual” as a foundation for their zoning code. This manual was part of the comp plan process and provided a bridge between the comp plan and zoning.
  • Cities are focusing more on URBAN DESIGN. In Nashville, they created an urban design studio even though they had to cut staff planners. Minneapolis is also creating an urban design studio.
  • Web site to take a look at: www.missingmiddlehousing.com – discusses the idea of flexible neighborhoods.
  •  In some areas, there is a tendency to bring new zoning trends to a city just because it’s new, NOT because it’s informed by policy and planning.
  • Remember that the greatest places in the world were created before zoning.
  • The outcome of any code-reform effort is not a better code – it’s a better cities.
  • Important to create an understanding in your community of what it costs to build things.
  •  Street design should be included in form zoning. Need to have the right street in the right place. Many complaints of streets that are too big.
  • Form districts are a legal advantage over design review committees which have a lot of discretion.
  • Visioning: how can this happen in communities that don’t have a lot of time and money? Answer: quick and dirty is fine. Ask the right questions, and get the right info to get you to the next step.

The next session as called “Parking and More (or Less) Parking.” This was the session in which I texted Mark constantly :P. It was a panel looking at three communities in the greater Seattle area – suburban and small city in character. Some highlights:

  •  The most-talked about web site was www.rightsizeparking.org, and the most talked about parking consultant was Rick Williams (interestingly, this is the same parking guru Michelle Rheems talked about earlier this year!). If I’d had access to a bar, I could’ve made a drinking game out of “rightsizeparking.org” and “Rick Williams.”
  •   In Kent, WA: they used to do retail parking right in front of retail, office right in front of office, etc. Did an overall approach to coordinate shared parking: Kent Downtown Partnership.
  • Kirkland, WA: they did a data-based study after learning they were expecting 8300 new multifamily units by 2035. They wanted to make sure they weren’t over- or under-parking. “The perception of a parking problem can be very different than what the data indicates.” They went from 2.2 parking stalls per unit to: 1 stall for a studio, 1.1 for 1 bdrm, 1.4 for 2 bdrm, 1.5 for 3 bdrm.
  • Tukwila, WA: Did parking counts at 2:00 am to determine need for overnight parking. City is facilitating shared use agreements with users. One developer on the panel said that having 15 to 30 minute parking in front of retailers is key for those businesses. He also said that the best mixed use scenario in terms of the most efficient use of parking is multifamily residential + office.
  • For years, development was driven by the parking code – these cities had codes that required 2.2 parking spaces per unit so ALL units developed were 2 bdrm units. Now, with new standards tailoring parking needs to # of bdrms per unit, they are seeing a surge in development of 1 bdrm and studio apartments.
  • Chicago recently privatized their on-street parking. Panelists weren’t necessarily recommending this, but noted it removed the political burden of increasing prices from the City, with the outcome that there are now stalls available and people don’t have to circle around looking for parking.
  • One recommendation in the King County study was to remove parking minimums. Keith will like that ;).

Zoning for Bikeability. A lot of the information (such as the 4 different classes of riders, the increase in bike commuting) is familiar to those of us working on the Superior Street project. This session shared ideas of what other cities are doing:
  • Bicycle parking ratios – Portland, OR (note we have similar requirements for bike parking in our Higher Education Overlay district)
  • Bike share incentive – City of Denver code
  •  Long-term bike storage requirements – Calgreen Building Code (CA)
  • Can convert an on-street parking space to bike parking for about 10 parking spaces.
  •  Focus on street connectivity standards for subdivisions (note – we already have this!)
  • Austin, TX: added protected bike lanes to their CIP projects. Started looking city-wide. This was pushed by a very progressive Council member.
  • Bike parking shouldn’t be any further away than the closest vehicle parking space
  • In Austin: developers pursuing PUDs have liked bike requirements as a negotiation tool.
  •  “Sometimes the best bike lane is no bike lane” – choose connectivity of your street network over bike lanes.
The second day, they had the opening keynote, I went to one session, then went on the mobile orientation tour. The one session I attended was Lessons Learned From Form-Based Codes. Three lessons I noted:
  1. The importance of a physical plan. The public realm – streets and sidewalks – are part of the plan.
  2. Be realistic about the market potential.
  3.   Don’t throw out the entire code if pieces of it aren’t working.
 On Monday, I attended two mobile tours. One was a tour of the award-winning public library (some parts of it I liked, but overall not my kind of library!). Then a whole afternoon learning about the City’s super ambitious waterfront project. They are rebuilding the entire seawall of the downtown area, miles and miles, funding entirely by local (City) money – it is costing millions of dollars. $350 million to be exact. The new seawall will be built to seismic standards and greatly improve habitat. They are building a sidewalk with a light penetrating surface so light can get to the water underneath for better fish habitat. Pretty cool. As part of a separate project, they are building the big tunnel (with the digger named “Bertha” that is currently stuck underground) to put an elevated highway underground, and create miles of new public waterfront, with a parkway, bike lanes, and parks. I want to go back in about 5 years and see what it looks like.

The final day of the conference, the keynote was Sustainability in a World Context. Sustainability, and specifically climate change and adaptability, were huge themes of the conference. This session pointed out that 60-70% of actions you can take on climate change are in the purview of local government. He used the example of Vancouver, which is not giving up on the Kyoto Protocol, and is focusing on district heating, a stringent building code, and a mode shift for transportation with a goal of 1/3 of the trips being in an automobile. In the UK, climate change planning is very top-down and local governments must comply with federal goals. The British National Planning Policy Framework creates a presumption in favor of sustainable development. Back in the US, the speaker noted that there is an increased trend towards metrics – towards collecting needed data. Also, the insurance industry is taking a huge interest in planning (even substantially funding initiatives) because increased planning for climate change reduces insurance risk. Interesting, huh?

The final full session I attended before heading to the airport was Challenges of Student Housing. This was convened by my aforementioned hero Don Elliott. He was a busy guy at the conference. Here is what Don and his panelists think about student housing:
  • We need to cater to private developers. If we (planners) get it wrong and the developers don’t come to the party, nothing happens.
  • Reuse is an interesting trend. In Denver, they are buying hotels and turning them into student housing. In West Virginia, developers have bought an old nursing home and are buying apartment buildings for students. Reuse can be good, but on the flip side – what if developers or schools start to buy a City’s affordable housing stock?
  •  Housing is not and should not be primarily the responsibility of colleges. “History shows that requiring employers get into housing is inefficient and provides second-rate housing.”
  •  Private student housing can occur where planners wouldn’t want density. This puts pressure on existing housing stock. There is a general housing crisis. “The failure to provide affordable housing is a structural problem of the American economy.”
  • Denver’s zoning ordinance says that if you have transit plus high-volume traffic, you should have density!
  • Challenges of student housing: there is scale and density where it hasn’t existed before; development tends toward inward-oriented design (parent concerns are about safety so buildings aren’t street-oriented); more cars leads to parking and traffic.
Without going into all the details, the trends in student housing are consistent with what we have seen here so far and what we will continue to see. Also, what other cities are doing with use-specific standards, form type standards, etc., are also things we are working towards. The biggest mental note I made is to continue to find ways to decrease the need for students to have cars, and to increase transit use.


--------------------------------------------


Flew out with my former intern Emily. So proud to have watched her career grow!

With my dear Sarah my first night in Seattle.

So lovely. Pike Place Market, sunshine, the mountains beyond.


The gum wall. Ewwww ....




The rooftop of Sarah and Evan's apartment, with a view of downtown. I spent an entire afternoon here in the sunshine reading a book. And there are vegetables growing for all the residents to use!

Gas Works Park

Evan and Sarah. Two of my favoritest people on the planet.


At Skillet Diner in Fremont. Best dinner of the trip.

My favorite place in Seattle. I went twice. It serves molten chocolate cakes and delicious sounding cocktails. It had a line out the door, packed tables, and loud music. A chocolate destination as a late-night hot spot? Count me in.

Agricola!

Met up with my friend Aly. Former grad school classmate, now Seattle city planner.

Construction site and entrance tunnel of the big dig.




No comments: