Tuesday, August 25, 2009

why the housing market won't pick up

As most of you know, Matt and I would like to build a house. I get a lot of questions about this -- why build when it's so expensive? Why not be more sustainable and buy an existing house, close to work? Why are you wanting to build outside the city?

a) Matt needs a photography studio with a separate entrance. Nearly impossible to find a house with this (or even one we could put an addition on).

b) We want to be in a place we can see wildlife, enjoy peace and quiet, and raise chickens if we want.

c) Little things we want could cost us a fortune to add to or remodel in an existing house -- root cellar, a gas cooking range, good cross ventilation, energy efficiency, etc.

d) Admittedly, we're a bit picky and spoiled. I simply can no longer imagine living without an attached garage or a master bath!

The beginning steps in this process have proven to be an education in the road blocks in the housing market ... i.e., why the housing market sucks!

Building is expensive. Especially custom building (versus a large company like, say, Centex, which can save money because of its sheer size). Based on my research, a 2000 square foot home in Duluth (which is still 700+ square feet less than our existing home) can easily cost over $400,000. In fact, I would doubt whether you could do it for less. Yikes! That's significantly more than we will get for the sale of our larger home in the Twin Cities.

We had a plan for this -- finishing much of the house ourselves. We thought we could hire a contractor to build the outside and take it through the sheetrock phase. We could install flooring, cabinets, trim, doors, etc. Here's where the shock began:

Lenders will not allow you to do this.

You are simply not allowed to do any of the work yourselves.

Impossible, right? I mean, it seems a common enough thing. However, in the recent housing crises many lenders were left with unfinished properties that clients were going to "build themselves." Banks are afraid of getting stuck with unfinished properties.

At what point is a house considered "finished" -- if it has a kitchen, bathroom, and say, a bedroom finished, is that enough?

I was thinking maybe we'd hire a contractor to finish certain things and consider it done ... even if the remaining rooms aren't completed using money from the mortgage and we would just finish it as we get money.

But they won't allow this. If ANYTHING is left unfinished in a house, the lender will not give you the mortgage. When you take possession from your contractor, it must be 100% complete, down to the last nail. The banker I talked to explained that some people are even having problems if there are a few pieces of trim missing.

Ok, this is a real problem. We're not sure if we have the money to build a 100% complete house. Is there no way anyone is allowing this? What if you have like amazing credit and a six figure income?

The answer to that was a big no. No ifs, ands, or buts.

OK, SERIOUSLY. One of our plans was to add a photography studio for my husband, and we thought that even if we can't afford it to be completed now, we'd have them frame it and we can complete it down the road. If the rest of the house is completed except this one room?

No can do. Absolutely no part of the house can be left unfinished and nothing can be "self-built."

The banker added that she knows people who actually work in residential construction but still are not allowed to "self build."

Come ON, people!!


Not that I am one to deny a talented worker a decent salary, but I can't help but feel outraged every time I think of this.

We aren't rich. We can't afford a $400-$500k house (and for that matter, WHO CAN?). No wonder the housing market isn't picking up!

Not only that, I see it a waste of money to pay a contractor to do this when I (and my family and friends) are talented, skilled, and perfectly capable of doing this work ourselves.

Moreover, the bank should be happy that we are interested in doing this work ourselves. Rather than have a bigger loan that we may not be able to make payments on, we would be building instant equity in our house! Our own labor would add value.

When the housing market tanked, it was everyday people who suffered when interest rates increased and they lost their homes. And even as "solutions" are being offered, everyday people are still suffering because of ridiculous regulations. It makes me think that if this continues, the housing market may never pick up, at least not until we can afford half a million dollar homes.

Saturday, August 22, 2009

A Day in My Life

by Hannah Moses

I was sleeping on my back, paws in the air, when my mom reached over and started rubbing my belly. Oh that felt so good! She stopped too soon though. She could have pet me all day! She got out of bed and went into the room with the water coming out from the wall (I don’t like that – I might get sprayed!). She called me to follow her and said she had to keep an eye on me (ever since they found out I’ve been sneaking food from a forgotten bag in the basement they’ve been watching me, darn it!). I’m obedient, and I love my mom, so I followed her, and took my first nap of the day, sleeping curled up in her bathrobe.

After her shower, I followed her and watched her as she rushed around, and then she turned and asked “Do you wanna go see Doug?” All I heard though was – “do ya wanna?” – and I said YES! I don’t care what it is, I always want to! And started talking and jumping to show her how excited I was. They like it when I tell them what I’m thinking! I ran to the door and didn’t even need mom’s help to open it – I opened it all by myself and went running to the car. I never understand why humans don’t run places. It’s so fun!

Here’s a picture of me in the car on my way to see Bonnie and Doug:


I like rides. I especially like them in trucks. Too bad mom doesn’t have a truck.

Mom let me out of the car at Bonnie and Doug’s and I thought – rabbits!! I started running through the yard looking for them but mom told me I had to go in the house. That’s ok, that’s where Bonnie and Doug are! I went running in and said good morning to them and told them they could pet me. At “Dougie day care” I spent my day running around the yard, sitting in Doug’s lap watching for rabbits (and telling him to pet me), and taking more naps. But I always listen for mom’s car. Here’s me sitting on Doug’s lap:


I barked at visitors who came—two guys named Uncle. To me they’re strangers though. I need to scare the strangers away because I don’t like them. I’m good at barking too! It worked because they FINALLY went away. I took more naps and kept listening for mom’s car.


After many hours she came back. I was so excited to see her!! I talked and talked to tell her. And then the excitement got to be too much and I had to go pounce on my toys! Here’s me with the toys at Bonnie and Doug’s:


My mom said something about a party, and soon we got in the car and went to a strange house. There was that guy named Uncle! Thankfully no one tried to pet me so I didn’t need to bark at them. We sat outside so I got to do my favorite thing: watch for rabbits and other critters! The deck railing provided a perfect pillow for my head as I watched:


I didn’t see any rabbits. But I could smell lots of stuff coming from the woods!

After awhile mom asked me if I wanted to “go for a” and of course I did! So even though it was dark we got in the car one last time, finally going “home” to Adam’s house. Adam and Molly were outside waiting for us! I was so excited to see Adam. I love talking to him too! We went inside and Molly was so excited she started running around. We ran and ran around the furniture until I was so tired I collapsed on Molly’s dog bed.

Mom made me move, saying we had to go to our real beds. She says I have a big day tomorrow – a long car ride, a play date with lots of other Brittanies, and then going to see Matt!! I better go to bed and get my beauty rest!

Thursday, August 13, 2009

Perseid Meteor Shower

We watched the meteor shower "together" last night - Matt on one end of the phone in Victoria, me on the other end in Cloquet, with Adam and the dogs out on the deck with me. It was very cool, and one meteor that we saw was quite large -- so exciting!

Check out this image that Matt captured.

Monday, August 10, 2009

it's official

The house is listed!

I thought I would share the pictures Matt took for our realtor:














Wednesday, August 05, 2009

Around City Hall

Things are off to a flying start, as I already feel stressed over project deadlines ;). I'm happy to say that I will not be bored in this job; there seems to be an endless amount of projects and work, with a wide variety of tasks. My calendar is filling up with meetings, including today's planning department retreat where we reviewed our department's business plan, reviewed tasks, brainstormed ideas, and assigned teams to projects. For you planner types out there -- things I will be working on (at least to start with) include permits and variances related to the Water Resource Management Ordinance, applications pertaining to street/utility vacations (which apparently is a unique issue to Duluth), the Downtown Waterfront Mixed-Use District Committee, tax forfeit lands from St. Louis County, Environmental Assessment Worksheets, maintaining the planning department's web page and public outreach efforts, an annual report for Skyline Parkway, GIS maps and data for the department, a Small Area Plan for the Waterfront, and developing a process for the citywide rezoning following adoption of our Unified Development Code. I love it!

I've been taking a few more pictures around City Hall. First up, an old mail chute - this is an old building that has character! -


The elevator indicator makes me feel like I'm living in the 40s (again, I love it):


Even the side door is ornate!


As mentioned in my previous post, the bathroom. Please appreciate the two-toned peeling orange paint, holes in the wall, the vent that has been taped to the wall, and the tiny toilet.


Finally, another view from my office:

Monday, August 03, 2009

first day

On my drive into Duluth this morning, Lake Superior had a beautiful fog blanketing the lake. On one hand it seemed like such a comfortable view--I've done this commute many times and know this area well. But on the other ... is this really me, commuting to Duluth for work? for my new job? This whole thing still seems surreal ... the job, the move, everything!

The first day of work went wonderfully well. First, I have an OFFICE - first office I've ever had to myself, with a door and everything! And not only that -- a WINDOW! This was beyond my expectations. Here's the view from my window--it looks over a plaza and the city, with the lake beyond.

Not too bad, huh?

Just when I thought this couldn't be topped, I was given a project right away (I HATE being bored, especially when you start a new job and don't know what to do with yourself).

Everyone was so friendly and nice, asking me questions and helping me find every last office supply I needed. I felt at home right away. And this morning when I heard a ship's horn through my open office window, it jolted me to the realization ... I'm back. I get to live in this super cool city.

The 4th floor departments have a coffee club. For $5 a month you get fresh Alakef coffee - mmmmm!

Oh - and this afternoon I got to meet the mayor!

Ok, now for the down sides ... it's slightly annoying to have to park a ways away and to pay for parking.

And, the bathrooms stink (ha ha, pun intended!) It's an old building after all - they're small and worn. Very annoying to have to straddle the toilet seat to shut the door, to have to do a 90 degree bend to flush the toilet, to have soap dispensers not work. So, if I could wave my magic wand that's the one thing I'd change ;).

But nothing is ever perfect, and I'm glad that the day went well. I'm looking forward to going back tomorrow.

Oh, and Hannah? I know many people are curious about how she adapted to her new surroundings.

She spent part of her day at Bonnie and Doug's today. My dad emailed me this message: "There's no way that Hannah feels comfortable here. I think she is just 'toying' with us." with this photo attached -

Hannah using toys as a pillow, snoozing away!

After this, she spent several hours home alone with Molly, and seemed to do well! Adam reported no barking or whining, either when I left this morning or when he left the two of them alone. No accidents, nothing destroyed in the house, so all is well.

I do miss my Matt, though!

Saturday, August 01, 2009

Real Estate Market in Duluth

As I've told people about our move to Duluth, nearly everyone has commented about how this "is a good time to buy" or about how "housing is cheaper in Duluth." Well ... I'm here to tell you this ain't exactly so. True, there are a lot more houses available for under $200k than there are in the Cities, but I'm surprised at the prices some houses are being listed at.

For example, check out this house in Esko. $329k for a 3 bedroom ranch built in 1985 (two of the bedrooms are small ... and a fourth bedroom is nonconforming). Interior has been updated but exterior is outdated, and overall, not a lot of space for the price.

Here's a four bedroom in Esko. Newer and a nice house ... but still, $400k? Isn't this supposed to be the "cheaper" market?

This home in Hermantown is very cute, but is the same price as we could likely end up selling our home for ... and yet it has a 2-car garage (ours currently has a 3-car garage), one fewer bedroom, and no possibility for expansion (our home currently has an unfinished basement). I just can't believe that the Duluth market in many ways seems more expensive than the market in our area of the Twin Cities.