Saturday, November 20, 2010

This Omnivore's Dilemma

I grew up in a hunting family, but somewhere along the way, right around high school, I decided I no longer wanted to be involved in eating meat, and became vegetarian. It wasn't really the healthiest choice, as I'm sure my nutrition was out of whack, but I stayed away from meat for several years. Until some point in college, where I a) started to really crave meat (probably because I needed the protein!) and b) started thinking really critically about sustainability and food choices. The more I learned about our food system, the more I began to believe that even vegetarians, if they're eating tofu and organic vegetables flown in from California or Chile and grown on massive farms owned by large corporations, aren't very sustainable. And the more I began to realize that the way I had eaten growing up was very local, healthy, and connected to the earth ... fresh vegetables out of the garden, my mom preserving fruits and vegetables for the winter, my dad hunting grouse and deer.

Wanting to live closer to nature was one of the reasons I wanted to move back north. We've gotten our wish. 20 acres of land for a garden, fruit trees, and hunting. We have soooo many deer out here that Matt started talking about possibly getting a deer license. This deer season, he's spent a lot of time either sitting in a blind or watching deer from the house, with no luck so far.

This morning he got out of bed and the dogs followed him, ready to go out for their morning bathroom break and really excited about breakfast. Matt scanned the yard for deer before letting them out, and saw two deer. He came to tell me "there's one deer laying down and another standing there eating." I told him to leave the dogs in the bedroom with me so they wouldn't bark or make noise, and he went to get his jacket and rifle. Less than five minutes later, we heard a loud crack from just outside the house. I couldn't believe it. Even though I grew up in a deer hunting family, I'd never actually been around when a deer was shot. I came out of the bedroom just as Matt was returning to the house. Adrenaline must have kicked in for him, because he held his hands out and they were shaking! He had shot the deer. Most importantly, it had been a good shot, so she had fallen quickly. I was proud of my husband for being a good shot!

But still, we could see her body twitching where she fell. And I looked over and instantly wanted to cry. It was heart wrenching to see her last minutes. And even more heart wrenching to realize this was the mama deer we had been watching since last spring. Her two fawns of the year were nearby (surprisingly not scared off by the shot) and every once in awhile would look in her direction as if they were waiting for her to lead them off through the woods. Tears sprang to my eyes -- it gets so personal when they're "your" animals that you feel like you know. I imagine this is somewhat how farmers must feel as well. These mixed emotions are the dilemma about eating meat, and really, about nature and life in general. We love animals, but we also choose to eat them. We can look for photo opportunities one day, and a hunting opportunity another day. And we try to find balance in that; while today it was about shooting a deer, we spent all fall deciding not to hunt the grouse outside our window because it was too enjoyable to watch them.

It is nature's way for some animals to die so that others might live. And since I choose to eat meat, I do believe that hunting them is one of the most sustainable, healthy, humane ways to do so. These deer grew up on this land, living naturally, with no hormones, grain, fences, or antibiotics. This is as local, free range, and organic as you can get. It does make me feel closer to nature to be more connected to my food source. Some of my food still does come nicely shrink wrapped from the grocery store; but I also know what it's like to grow my own vegetables, clean birds, and help butcher a deer. In a strange way, it is awe-inspiring to be given a gift of an animal like this. I also know, logically, that there are far too many deer in our area (we live in an "intensive" area where Matt could have shot up to 5 deer if he wanted), and that harvesting deer helps maintain the population and will likely make it easier for those fawns to survive through the winter.

I went outside with Matt to tag his deer, and insisted on bringing a camera, so proud to photograph his first deer!! When I walked down there, I told the mama deer that she had done a really good job raising her fawns this year and said a silent prayer of thanks for the meals she would provide us.

And I helped capture the moment for posterity:

Congrats, Matt, on your first deer!

Matt had called my dad, who was at the hunting shack. My dad said he'd drive back immediately to help gut the deer, since Matt hadn't done it before. He and my uncle Roger arrived about an hour later, eager to act as coaches, and the three of them went directly out to the deer. The dogs and I watched from the house, and based on the dogs' reactions I suspect they knew exactly what happened. I'm not sure how, because they couldn't actually see the deer from here, but maybe they had smelled the deer when they were outside, and knew that all the guys were out in the direction of the deer. They were nearly bouncing off the walls, shaking and crying with hysteria they were so excited.

Before long, the guys were hauling the deer back towards the house, and into my dad's truck so they could haul it to Adam's house.

Good thing we bought that four wheeler!

My Uncle Roger, my dad, and Matt

Tomorrow we will start butchering, and it will be a busy day, as we have Matt's deer as well as my dad's to take care of!

Before bringing the deer to Adam's, the guys had cut out the tenderloins. We created a wonderful celebration dinner tonight ... delicious venison tenderloins (how fresh can meat get??), roasted sweet potatoes, steamed vegetables, biscuits, apple pie, and Matt even opened one of our Colorado bottles of wine. My parents came to help us celebrate, and we had a wonderful evening talking about everything from deer hunting to the pending arrival of baby Moses. Although the day started with a little sadness, at the end of the day I can look back and feel like it was an absolutely remarkable day, a day to remember, a day to make me feel inordinately blessed and fortunate in this world.

No comments: